Start Page Update list
Speakers
Amplifiers
Transport
Lampucera
Alphabetical
Tripath
Download Lampizator
TDA1541A
September 2nd 2009


Akai CD37 with Stelmach DAC

I love AKAI for their tape recorders - reel to reel old machines and also cassette tape three head machines. That company used to be very very close to high end. But at some point they lost it. CD players were not nearly as good as three head tape decks. Below is an example of a good player that was just okay, but not high end by all means.






CD-37 is a medium player, not the top league even from AKAI.



Just look what they were proud of: Digital output and  random program. Hardly something to get us excited. And they used three fonts to communicate that iffy success.






\






Advanced interpolative dulal converter - it is anothey way of saying : this player has a converter.





The owner of this player installed a Polish made Stelmach DAC instead of the original Burr Brown PCM-1701. Stelmach DAC is very popular and famous in Poland. Lets see whats inside.







The mechanism is based on a Sony KSS210 A basic simple and cheap laser.  Akai mechanism is made of plastic, it is not very impressive. Just an OK plastic mechanism. Nothing comparable to the best Sony mechanisms like BU1 / kss190A.











Stelmach DAC



This is the Stelmach DAC board - with cristall CS4398 DAC chip and all power supply regulators and input section.
The DAC chip seems to be fantastic one, we know it can play well. It is similar to the Lampucera DAC CS4397 and to the Zhalou DAC2,5 (identical chip).





Above is the DAC and it's surrounding circuitry.  Note that this chip is configured as monoponic hence we have TWO OF THEM. The four resistors on the left side of DAC - standing in upright position - are the four signals from DAC . Mormally in stereo that would be - L+, L-, R+ and R-.. In mono - they are on one chip L+, L-, L+, L- and the same for the other channel.
We can tap our lampizator input from there.
 




These chips numbered from 01 to 13 are PROBABLY the logical chips from 74CXX series that enable this DAC to be connected to any digital circuit - translating any digital format like Philips i2S or Sony - to the format acceptable by the DAC.  In this mode Stelmach DAC can work in ANY circiut there exists.  The good thing is taht the DAC uses the direct digital signal, not SPDIF.  So we are two big steps closer  to the "true" information.
Effectively the CD player with Stelmach becomes an INTEGRATED PLAYER  and not like a transport and DAC.  This is definitely the way to go.
The player will loose its own character and the Stelmach / Cirrusa signature will dominate. Theroretically it wil not matter anymore what spins the disc - Sony, Rotel, Akai, or Revox.
I like that product. I wish it had tubes added from the beginning.








Above - you can see two dac chips in symmetrical fashion.


Stelmach dac is really beautifully made, with very nice PCB, many many goodies like all caps with a small bypass, premium parts, neat layout, and everything looking like top league high-end.
However, having said that - I was expecting a better sound.

Listening test

Stelmach dac in AKAI produced an uninvolving sound, somehow small, laid back, not too detailed. Apparently all was there, nothing to complain, but - I expected more. I had a preconception about the Cirrus / Cristal DAC that it should be more musical, more immediate, with a kind of  "spark".  I listened to it for an hour and I gave up. As much as I liked the DAC board itself, there was not enough quality for me. Maybe something was wrong. I cant honestly tell.
I lampized it for a moment with my boxed external lampizator but still no big success. DAC was still rather uninvolving. It was like driving an Opel Vectra 1,6 - OKAY to get from A to B but nothing to write home about. I really dont know where Mr. Stelmach went wrong. Or is it me?   It is not the opamps because lampizator was not better. Is it the digital part before DAC ? Is it supply ? I dunno.  MAybe the dac is so pure and natural that it is not impressive, it is just honest, and it takes more than a while to accomodate to that style, to appreciate it, to discover new quality. Like with top wines - they are addictive not after the first sip. The cheap wines are designed and engineered to impress after first sip.
I cant recommend it seriously, but I very much encourage you toio try it and draw your own conclusion.  For a long time I havent seen a product made so well and I hope that eventually this DAC will succeed, even if this applies only to Polish market.
An interesting case maybe to be solved later by someone.  Maybe I will contact Mr. Stelmach and ask for guidance how to use this product optimally, how to connect it to LAmpizator etc.

Back to Akai - I think that lampized AKAI with its ow great PCM1701 DAC would be better ,  judging by the great result with the same dac chip inside the Luxman CD103 player.





Start Page Update list
Speakers
Amplifiers
Transport
Lampucera
Alphabetical
Tripath
Download Lampizator
TDA1541A